Ministers told to give longer term pledge on bonds

Ministers told to give longer term pledge on bonds

David McMillan

Scottish ministers have been told to set out a clear case for issuing government bonds with a long term commitment if investors are to offer their support.

John Swinney’s government wants to sell £300m of bonds each year for five years, but experts have warned that investors need certainty over their purpose and longevity.

A reason for issuing bonds is to establish Scotland’s credibility in the international money markets, particularly if the country should become independent, reports Daily Business.

Angus Macpherson, former co-chair of the Scottish Government’s investor panel, told Holyrood’s finance committee that the development of bonds would “improve dialogue between the government and investors, particularly among international investors who want to understand Scotland’s story.”

David McMillan, a professor in finance at Stirling University, said that continuity was an important factor in building credibility with investors along with a specific rationale to justify the high fees associated with bonds.

“You have to get it into the minds of the people that it is for the people and that there is a tangible benefit, and you will stick to it,” he said. “That builds credibility in the market.”

He added: “I would not design a programme that says, in five years’ time, we will think about it, because investors are looking for permanence in the nature of the programme. There is a benefit in having a programme that doesn’t end after five years and has a range of maturities.”

There have been warnings at previous meetings of the committee that, because of high fees, a bond would cost the taxpayer more than borrowing from the National Loans Fund and this would need to be factored into the sum raised and the term.

Dr Ben Cormier, senior lecturer at Strathclyde University, said the issuing of bonds would bring greater flexibility to Scottish government financing but agreed on the need to tie the proceeds to a definite outcome.

Auditor General Stephen Boyle warned that without any roll-over arrangement at the end of the five-year term, the bond would have to repaid and this would require adjustments in the Scottish budget.

“What we’ve seen over recent years is an increasing complexity with the Scottish Government’s budget arrangements, particularly up until now with budget reconciliations that add volatility that have to be accounted for. This would be another new complexity,” he said.

Lenaic Couderc, an assistant vice president with Moody’s Ratings, told the committee that Scotland’s credit rating, which matches the UK’s, was “very much a rating based on the current set of circumstances”. That includes Scotland’s place in the UK and the likelihood of the UK Government stepping in if anything went wrong.

Dr Cormier was asked whether markets were pricing in the prospect of independence by 2031. “I think it’s priced in, ” he said, “but they don’t see a high likelihood of that happening.

Join Scotland's business professionals in receiving our FREE daily email newsletter
Share icon
Share this article: