UK at risk of Brexit brain drain, warns ACCA Scotland
With the UK government seemingly committed to sacrificing freedom of movement in pursuit of a ‘hard’ Brexit, the Association of Chartered Certified Accountants (ACCA) Scotland has warned that the country could face a ‘brain drain’ of top professionals.
Sterling has taken another dramatic fall following policy announcements at last week’s Conservative Party conference and ACCA Scotland has called on the business community to “take a firm position on explaining the potential harms that stringent immigration restrictions could have on the British economy for many years ahead”.
Craig Vickery, head of ACCA Scotland, says that while governmental focus on skills and training for UK citizens is welcome, it is wrong to sideline freedom of movement from its economic strategy.
He said: “It is no secret that there is a shortage of skilled workers in many sectors and specialisms, particularly in the STEM related areas. This challenge has been mitigated in part by access to skilled labour from other parts of the world, particularly from the EU. However, with the UK’s imminent departure from the EU the challenge to business of accessing highly skilled and specialist talent could be further exacerbated.
“The drive towards apprenticeships as a way of skilling-up young people and opening new pathways into professional careers, such as accountancy, is a step in the right direction. But it will take time for the next generation of highly skilled talent to hit the workforce, and restrictions to movement may well prevent UK businesses from benefiting from a global talent pool in the here and now.”
Mr Vickery also explained that there is a risk that the current debate overlooks the potential for ‘brain drain’ as the UK’s top talent seek opportunity in other, more stable economies.
He warned: “There is a risk that talent could leave or be poached from the UK as we enter into an extended period of limbo whilst the UK seeks to reinvent itself post-Brexit.
“Consultation with our members and students indicates that they are much more willing to work globally than ever before – we saw a spike in enquiries from British citizens looking to live and work in Australia, New Zealand and Canada in the weeks that followed the Brexit vote. Given the criteria for securing a working visa in those countries it is certainly conceivable that it would be some of the UK’s more highly skilled workers who will be seeking opportunities in other parts of the world thus potentially creating the beginnings of a brain drain.
“Recruitment specialist Robert Half reported this week that demand is already outstripping supply for key accountancy and finance positions, so even a relatively small exodus of talent could have significant consequences.
Mr Vickery also argues that this is not just a problem for traders at leading City banks, but will lead to a potential drain of talent and experience from across the UK’s professions,
He said: “This is not just a problem confronting London-based multinational firms. This profound affects Edinburgh as a major UK finance sector and many other areas, such as Glasgow and Aberdeen, whose local economies thrive from world-leading UK success in industries such as pharmaceuticals, IT, popular culture and design.
“An example is the higher education sector, where fears of loss of research funding may see UK universities struggling to attract or retain the best staff to carry out the research that drives knowledge discovery and supports the reputation of UK higher education through the international league tables.”
Mr Vickery, however, does believe that the Government is on the right path in targeting productivity, but that it must show patience with its new industrial strategy,
He added: “Productivity – remains a huge challenge for the UK economy. Productivity has failed to recover from the 2008 crisis and today output per hour in the UK is 25 per cent lower than in Germany, the US and France.
“There has been no post-recession bounce in productivity.
“To contextualise if the UK’s pre-financial crisis trend had continued, productivity today would be more than 16% higher. Wages and living standards would be substantially higher than today – the importance of productivity should therefore not be underestimated – particularly as Westminster and Holyrood look to build an economy that works for all.
“If we are to compete globally we need to go back to basics. This week Michael Heseltine called for the new industrial strategy to start in primary schools – and he has a valid point. If we are to nurture the highly skilled talent that the UK will need to thrive in an increasingly competitive global environment then we need to ensure that schools are suitably resourced to provide children with the right foundations.
“Without investment in technology, in training and development and, of course education, productivity is unlikely to rise by any significant degree.”